The Best Heavy Metal Album Ever Tournament: Part II

Let's Continue the Tournament: Final Opening Round Matchups

Heavy Metal!

**Voting for Part II has closed.  Click Here to vote on the next round of matchups.**

It’s time for you to vote on the final eight opening round matchups of the Best Metal Album Ever Tournament.   This week’s battles will take place in the regions of Massachusetts and New York.  The first eight matchups were completed and voted on over the last week and we have some pretty interesting results that pose some really great matchups in the next round (The Screaming Sixteen). Before we can get to that next week, please vote on these final album matchups to see who else will move onto the final sixteen. 

For those of you who missed the first part of the tournament, you can check it out here: The Best Metal Album Ever: Part I.  This is a thirty-two album single elimination tournament, just like the NCAA basketball tournament, to crown the best metal album of all time that is voted on by you, the readers.  Voting for the following opening matchups will be open until 11:59 pm on Wednesday March 14, 2012. 

Before we get to last week’s results, here is a quick refresher on the rules and how the tournament will commence.  The readers will be given a background and critical opinions for the albums in each matchup.  In addition, each album will have two YouTube videos associated with it in their opening round matchups to help make the best decision.  Each round after, the band will be represented by one video and then the two albums in the championship will be represented by their three most well-known videos.  So I don't continually repeat myself in each leaf, this will be the final article to contain album descriptions and critical opinions.  If you need to go back and look, I will have links to the first two articles in all proceeding articles and you can also click on the Amazon links for information and fan reviews. After reading and viewing each matchup, there will be a link for you to vote on which album is better.  Only one album per band is allowed in the tournament, so the bands will be represented by their best album.    Voting for each week will close on Wednesday at 11:59 and the leaf for the next week of matchups will be posted on Thursday.  The winning album will have an entire leaf dedicated to it at the end of the six week period and a top ten list will be created.

Week One Results

Scandinavian and San Francisco Regions

Paranoid (1) 100% defeated Comalies (8) 0%

Black Metal (4) 67% defeated Dirt (5) (33%)

Rust in Peace (3) 100% defeated The Powerless Rise (6) 0%

Upset Special:

The Art of Balance (7) 67% defeated Holy Diver 33% (2)

 

This sets up matches in the Screaming Sixteen of Paranoid vs. Black Metal and Rust in Peace vs. The Art of Balance.

 

 

Ace of Spades (1) 51% defeated Anthems of Rebellion (8) 49%

Badmotorfinger (4) 51% defeated Slaughter of the Soul (5) 49%

Vulgar Display of Power (3) 67% defeated Alive or Just Breathing 33%

Blizzard of Ozz (2) 100% defeated Dusk and Her Embrace (7) 0%

 

The screaming 16 matchups in this region will be Ace of Spades vs. Badmotorfinger and Vulgar Display of Power vs. Blizzard of Ozz next week.

Brackets

New York Region

Opening Round Matches

New York City Seranade

British Steel vs. Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia

Angel Dust vs. Rage Against the Machine

Arise vs. The Fall of Ideals

Reign in Blood vs. Hate Crew Deathroll

Brisith Steel (1) vs. Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia (8)

Judas Priest vs. Dimmu Borgir

British Steel
Columbia
Amazon.com: $5.00

British Steel (1) was released in 1980 by Judas Priest.  It was their sixth album and it was the album that saw them permanently change their style from hard rock to heavy metal.  Priest was one of the first bands to really embrace the term heavy metal.  The album reached 34 on the Billboard chart and 4 on the UK album charts and to this day is still one of the most recognizable heavy metal albums ever released.  It is considered to be the first album to really define the heavy metal sound with dual guitar sounds that are used by the majority of bands today.  The most well-known tracks on the album are “Breaking the Law”, “Living After Midnight”, and “Rapid Fire”. 

Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia
Nuclear Blast
Amazon.com: $8.99

Dimmu Borgir put out their fifth album, Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia (8) in 2001.  This album saw them begin to use interludes with clean vocals and is one of the first Black Metal albums to embrace the use of an orchestra instead of a keyboard.  Many Black Metal bands have followed suit since the release of this album.  The album is known for its great production and is widely considered to be their signature album.  The songs “Kings of Carnival Creation”, “Hybrid Stigmata”, and the cover of Twisted Sister’s “Burn in Hell” from Pee Wee’s Big Adventure are awesome songs. 

"Breaking the Law" and "Living After Midnight" vs. "Kings of Carnival Creation" and "Burn in Hell"

YouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnail

Cast Your Vote

British Steel or Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia?

Angel Dust (4) vs. Rage Against the Machine (5)

Faith No More takes on Rage Against the Machine

Angel Dust [Explicit]
London Records
Amazon.com: $9.49

Angel Dust (4) is the breakthrough album released by Faith No More in 1992.  Most people know their album The Real Thing because of the track “Epic”, but Angel Dust was a truly revolutionary album that blended metal, rap, country, death metal, punk, folk, and funk all into one.  It highly influenced Progressive bands like Tool and Nu Metal bands to experiment with different sounds.  Many magazines had it as an album of the year candidate.  It hit 10 on the Billboard charts and 2 on the UK album charts.  It was very successful for something with a very non-commercial sound.  Check out the songs “Land of Sunshine”, “Caffeine’, and “Midlife Crisis”

Rage Against The Machine
Epic
Amazon.com: $6.99

Rage Against the Machine (5) is the debut album from the band of the same name released in 1992.  This album was the first by any metal band that fully embraced the mix of rap and metal.  It is probably the most consistent and successful rap/rock album of all time.  This album influenced everyone from Korn to All That Remains.  Tom Morello’s unique guitar sounds that were almost like turntables had never been heard before and many other metal bands began to experiment with them after the release of this album.  So many great Rage songs are contained here.  It would be impossible to pick a few as they are all well-known and the album is great front to back.  The album is ranked at 368 on Rolling Stone’s list of 500 greatest albums of all time and reached  45 on the Billboard charts at a time when metal was not popular. 

"Land of Sunshine" and "Caffeine" vs. "Bombtrack" and "Killing in the Name"

YouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnail

Time to Vote

Angel Dust or Rage Against the Machine?

Arise (3) vs. The Fall of Ideals (6)

Sepultura against All That Remains

Arise (Reissue) [Explicit]
Roadrunner Records
Amazon.com: $9.49

Arise (3) is considered to be the best album the Brazilian band, Sepultura has ever released.  Fans still flock to buy it to this day and it was a successful thrash album in 1991, when thrash and metal were on a huge decline.    They began using some more groove type riffs and rhythms to appeal to fans of bands like Pantera.  The album also experiments with industrial sounds, punk rock, and native South American percussion.  It has been called a classic of both thrash and death metal.  It is known for the songs “Arise”, “Murder” and “Altered State”. 

The Fall of Ideals
Prosthetic/Razor & Tie
Amazon.com: $6.99

The Fall of Ideals (6) is the breakthrough and influential album released by All That Remains in 2006.  It was the first album to fully use the signature sound that they created.  The sound is a mix of melodic death metal and metalcore.  It has great lyrics, vocals, and blazing guitar riffs.  It influenced other metalcore bands, like As I Lay Dying, to go in a similar direction.  I consider this to be the best metal album of the last decade and many critics would agree, as it really revolutionized the metalcore subgenre.  Their track “Six” is a featured song on Guitar Hero II and the album reached 75 on the Billboard charts which is unbelievable for a local Massachusetts band with an independent record deal.  “This Calling” and “The Air I Breathe” are the singles from the album.  Check it out, you will be pleasantly surprised. 

"Altered State" and "Murder" vs. "This Calling" and "The Air I Breathe"

YouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnail

Punch the Ballot

Arise or The Fall of Ideals?

Reign in Blood (2) vs. Hate Crew Death Roll (7)

Slayer grapples with Children of Bodom

Hate Crew Deathroll
Spinefarm Records/ Fontana International
Amazon.com: $9.49

Hate Crew Deathroll (7) hit the shelves in 2003 and is considered to be the best album by Finnish Extreme Metal band, Children of Bodom.  On this album, they began to mix more of a thrash sound with their death metal elements.  They toned down their keyboard use and focused more on loud fast guitar riffs.   It was a commercial success in Europe reaching number one on the Finnish charts and 2 on the UK album charts.  This album has the perfect mix of aggression, complexity, and great musicianship.  “Needled 24/7”, “Sixpounder”, and “Angels Don’t Kill” are amongst some of the best extreme metal tracks ever. 

"Angel of Death" and "Jesus Saves" vs. "Sixpounder" and "Angels Don't Kill"

YouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnail

It's Voting Time

Reign in Blood or Hate Crew Deathroll?

Massachusetts Region

Opening Round Matches

Boston_Exterior_0001

Number of the Beast vs. Adrenaline

Just Look Around vs. Korn

Sound of White Noise vs. Clayman

Master of Puppets vs. Ashes of the Wake

Number of the Beast (1) vs. Adrenaline (8)

Iron Maiden tangles with The Deftones

Adrenaline
Rhino
Amazon.com: $8.99

Adrenaline (8) is the first release from Nu Metal pioneers The Deftones in 1995.  They were one of the first to take the sounds that Rage used and expand on them.  The percussion was very complex and used hip hop beats.  The guitars were groove based and had an element of turn table sounds.  Lead singer, Chino Mareno, mixed deep death metal growls with almost falsetto interludes.  It was different than anything that had come before it.  This is easily one of the best Nu Metal albums ever, as it came before bands sold out and relied too much on hip hop and bad lyrics.  This album is a benchmark of what Nu Metal should have been.  It has sold over 1 million copies worldwide with little to no radio airplay.  The songs “Root”, “Bored”, and “Minus Blindfold” are great examples of the sound they created.

Let's Go to the Polls

Numer of the Beast or Adrenaline?

"The Number of the Beast" and "Children of the Damned" Vs. "Root" and"Minus Blindfold"

YouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnail

Just Look Around (4) vs Korn (5)

Sick of It All fights against Korn

Just Look Around [Explicit]
Relativity Records
Amazon.com: $6.99

Just Look Around (4) released in 1992 is the most important and influential album released by New York Hardcore band Sick of It All.  This was one of the first albums to mix Hardcore Punk with Thrash and would pave the way for metalcore bands in the late 90’s and 2000’s.  It was amazing to hear really fast and grooving guitars mixed with hardcore vocals and punk breakdowns.  If it were not for this album, the metal bands popular today like, Killswitch Engage and All That Remains, would not exist.   This album should not be overlooked.  Take a listen to the tracks “We Want the Truth”, “Shut Me Out”, and “Just Look Around”, and you will hear the influence this album has had on the current metal scene. 

"Just Look Around" and "We Want the Truth" vs. "Ball Tongue" and "Blind"

YouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnail

Vote Now!

Just Look Around or Korn?

Sound of White Noise (3) vs. Clayman (6)

Anthrax versus In Flames

Sound of White Noise - Expanded Edition
Megaforce
Amazon.com: $9.99

Anthrax fired original singer, Joey Belladonna, and released a slower less thrash sounding album in 1992 with John Bush from Armored Saint on vocals.  The Sound of White Noise (3) is widely considered to be one of their best and most fans feel that Bush brought a lot more to the table on vocals and lyrics.  On this album they went to a heavier and more groove based sound that worked really well with Bush’s deep raspy voice.  It produced some of the bands most well-known material, like “Only”, “Black Lodge”, “Room for One More”, and “Hy Pro Glo”.  It debuted very high at number 7 on the Billboard chart and has been certified platinum.  This album would influence some other thrash bands to go in a similar direction and would be one the albums to pave the way for metal to get back into the mainstream.

Clayman
Good Fight Music
Amazon.com: $6.99

Clayman (6) is the sixth album released by In Flames and saw the band move from death metal to a more technical and precise melodic death metal sound.  Clean vocals were added to the death metal growl and the musicianship became a lot tighter.  This album would influence metalcore bands, like All That Remains, to use more melodic growling vocals and well produced guitar riffs.  This would be the sound that would make them one of the most successful and recognized Scandinavian metal bands and would cause a huge shift to a more melodic sound in death metal.  “Bullet Ride”, “Only for the Weak”, and “Clayman” are amongst the best songs ever released by the band. 

"Only" and "Hy Pro Glo" vs. "Clayman" and "Only for the Weak"

YouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnail

Time to Decide

Sound of White Noise or Clayman?

Master of Puppets (2) vs. Ashes of the Wake (7)

Metallica takes on Lamb of God

Ashes Of The Wake [Explicit]
Epic
Amazon.com: $5.99

Ashes of the Wake (7) is the Master of Puppets of the Neo Thrash movement.    This Lamb of God album released in 2004 really influenced the rebirth of thrash and like Master; it’s a perfect example on how to produce the perfect sounding metal album.  I thought it only proper for these two albums to go against each other, but remember without Master, this album would never have existed.  I again recommend checking out the whole album, as it is spectacular. 

"Battery" and "Welcome Home (Sanitarium)" vs. "Laid to Rest" and "Ashes of the Wake"

YouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnailYouTube Video thumbnail

Voice Your Choice

Master or Puppets or Ashes of The Wake?

Tournament Week 3

The Screaming Sixteen

Voting for week two is closed.  Click here to vote on the next round.

Photo Credits

The Essential Heavy Metal Albums

The Pioneers

Heavy metal fans have very varied opinions about the genre.  You have the one extreme where you ask a self proclaimed metal fan, what's ... Read more

The Best Heavy Metal Album Ever Tournament: Part III

Scream and Shout

**Voting for Part III has closed. Click here to vote on Part IV.**The opening round matchups of the Best Metal Album Ever Tournament are now complete,... Read more

The Best Heavy Metal Album Ever Tournament: Part IV

Evil

**The voting for Part IV has closed.  Click here to vote on Part V**Your voting has narrowed the field down from thirty-two of the best heavy... Read more

The Best Heavy Metal Album Ever Tournament: Part V

Four Candles

**Voting for this round has closed.  Please click here to vote on the final round**The results from last week’s Evil Eight Regional Finals ... Read more

Metallica vs. Megadeth: The Best Heavy Metal Album Ever

Welcome, Metalheads!

**Voting for finals has closed.  Click here to see who won and who is in the top 10**This is the moment everyone has been waiting for.&nb... Read more

The 25 Best Heavy Metal Albums Ever - Voted by Metal Fans

25

We have finally done it.  You, the readers, have voted over the past six weeks and selected the best heavy metal album of all time out of a f... Read more

Did You Vote?

Let Me Know

Who did you vote for? 

Comments

#
101 leaves
2106 forum posts
bill on said:
All That Remains, Master of Puppets, Sound of White Noise, Reign in Blood, Dimmu Borgir, Angel Dust, and Adrenaline were my picks for this round.
#
11 leaves
2 forum posts
Some interesting picks here. Did you check out the In Flames Youtube videos? I think you might be surprised about how much you would like them. They are like a mix of All That Remains, Korn, and Arch Enemy. I think Adrenaline is a great album but definitely check out Number of the Beast if you haven't yet. I thought I wasn't a Maiden fan until I wrote my Essential article and decided to download the album. It's surprisingly one of my favorite albums right now.
#
101 leaves
2106 forum posts
bill on said:
Just watched the In Flames videos, I forgot how good they were. I've honestly only heard a handful of Iron Maiden songs, so I will check out Number of the Beast. Looking for a good new album to listen to.

Add new comment